Unveiling the Secrets: What Makes a Film a Best Picture Contender?

Every year, as the Oscars approach, the world turns its eyes to the contenders for Best Picture. This coveted award is often seen as the pinnacle of cinematic achievement, recognizing a film’s overall excellence in storytelling, direction, and performances. But what exactly makes a film a Best Picture contender? Is it merely the sum of these individual elements, or is there something more that propels certain films to the forefront of award season?

In this article, we’ll dive into the intricate factors that contribute to a film’s journey to the Oscars. We will explore key aspects such as storytelling, direction, performances, cultural relevance, and timing, all of which play pivotal roles in a film’s potential to win this prestigious award.

Understanding the Ingredients of a Best Picture Contender

To understand what makes a film a Best Picture contender, we must first acknowledge that there is no single recipe for success. However, certain recurring themes and qualities tend to surface in many of the most beloved and acclaimed films. Here’s a breakdown of the critical elements:

1. Strong Storytelling

At the heart of every award-worthy film is an engaging, well-crafted story. The plot must resonate with audiences and critics alike, offering something fresh or thought-provoking. Storytelling involves not just the narrative arc but also the pacing, character development, and emotional depth.

• Character Complexity: Best Picture nominees often feature multi-dimensional characters whose emotional journeys evoke empathy and introspection. Characters who experience significant growth or who face morally ambiguous decisions tend to stand out.
• Originality: While adaptations of books or historical events can be successful, the film industry often favors originality. Fresh, innovative concepts or unexpected twists that subvert traditional genres tend to grab attention.
• Thematic Resonance: Films that address universal themes, such as love, loss, injustice, or human resilience, have a way of connecting with wide audiences. A story that holds cultural or emotional significance often stays in the public consciousness long after the credits roll.

2. Direction that Captivates

The director’s vision is paramount when it comes to shaping a film’s success. A skilled director knows how to extract the best performances from actors, manage complex narratives, and create visual compositions that enhance the story. Directors who can merge artistic vision with commercial appeal tend to have the greatest chances of success during awards season.

• Artistic Vision: Best Picture nominees frequently feature directors with a distinct style that is instantly recognizable. Directors like Christopher Nolan, Quentin Tarantino, and Greta Gerwig have built careers based on their unique approaches to filmmaking.
• Cinematic Innovation: Some films are contenders because they push the boundaries of filmmaking technology or narrative technique. Whether it’s the groundbreaking visual effects in films like “Avatar” or the use of time manipulation in “Dunkirk,” Best Picture contenders often include innovative cinematic techniques that leave a lasting impact.
• Direction of Performances: The director’s ability to draw out powerful performances from actors is critical. Films where the director skillfully guides actors through emotionally complex scenes or conveys nuanced subtleties are more likely to garner attention.

3. Performances that Leave an Impact

No film can succeed without stellar performances. While the Best Actor and Best Actress categories acknowledge individual performances, the ensemble cast is also essential in contributing to the overall success of a film. Powerful performances create lasting impressions, making films more memorable and deserving of critical acclaim.

• Emotional Range: The best performances often come from actors who display incredible emotional depth, whether through a quiet, subtle portrayal or an intense, dramatic transformation. A transformative role can be a game-changer for a film’s Best Picture chances.
• Chemistry and Ensemble Work: In films with large casts, the chemistry between actors can elevate a film. A well-knit ensemble cast that supports one another without overshadowing individual performances can make a film feel cohesive and greater than the sum of its parts.

4. Cultural Relevance and Social Commentary

Films that tackle pressing social, political, or cultural issues are often in the running for Best Picture. These films resonate with the zeitgeist of the time, capturing the mood of the moment. In recent years, films such as “Parasite” and “Nomadland” have garnered attention for their exploration of class inequality and economic hardship.

• Current Events and Reflection of Society: A Best Picture contender might not necessarily be about a current event, but it must reflect a broader societal trend or issue. Films that spark conversation or provoke thought about issues such as inequality, identity, or human rights can draw attention during the awards race.
• Global Appeal: In an increasingly globalized world, films that transcend national borders or offer a window into different cultures have a higher chance of being recognized. “Parasite,” which won the Academy Award for Best Picture in 2020, was a prime example of this shift.

5. Timing and Strategic Campaigning

While the quality of a film is paramount, timing plays a significant role in the success of a Best Picture contender. The film industry is highly competitive, and a well-timed release can help a film gain momentum heading into the fall and winter months, when award-season buzz is building.

• Release Strategy: Films that are released during the traditional “awards season” (October through December) have a better chance of being fresh in voters’ minds when nominations are made. Early releases can sometimes be overshadowed by stronger competition later in the season.
• Strategic Campaigning: The Academy Awards race has become a highly publicized event, and films that mount an effective awards campaign — whether through screenings, interviews, or social media promotion — can generate buzz that propels them into the limelight.

Exploring the Role of Critical Reception and Public Opinion

Critical acclaim is an essential factor in determining whether a film can compete for Best Picture. The opinions of critics often shape public perception, and strong reviews from respected outlets like Rotten Tomatoes or Metacritic can give films the visibility they need to stay in the conversation. However, public opinion also plays a crucial role.

• Critics’ Consensus: A strong critical consensus can make a huge difference in a film’s journey to the Oscars. Films that are universally praised for their craft, performances, and emotional weight are more likely to be remembered during nomination time.
• Audience Reactions: Although the Academy has shifted in recent years to be more inclusive of diverse voices and opinions, the tastes of the broader audience still matter. Films that resonate with mass audiences tend to gain traction as potential contenders, influencing both the public discourse and the perception of voters.

Conclusion: The Perfect Storm of Best Picture Contenders

While there is no magic formula for a Best Picture winner, films that combine strong storytelling, visionary direction, standout performances, and cultural relevance often stand the best chance. Timing and campaigning are also essential factors in securing a place in the coveted list of nominees. Ultimately, the film that resonates the most with both critics and audiences — while striking a chord with the Academy’s voting body — will find itself in the conversation for the most prestigious award in film.

In the end, the path to Best Picture is as much about craft as it is about timing, context, and momentum. As the landscape of film continues to evolve, one thing remains clear: the Best Picture contender is often a reflection of the cultural zeitgeist and a testament to the filmmakers’ ability to capture the world as it is — or, in some cases, as it could be.

For more insights into the Oscars and film industry trends, check out our official Oscar page.

See more CNET Live