Hidden Gems: Discover These 3 Underrated Netflix Shows This Weekend
As the weekend approaches, Netflix subscribers often find themselves scrolling endlessly through the platform’s vast library, searching for something fresh and compelling. This article highlights three underrated Netflix shows that deserve more attention. These hidden gems—ranging from dark comedies to gripping dramas—offer unique storytelling and standout performances, making them perfect for your next binge-watch session.
Why These Underrated Netflix Shows Are Worth Your Time
With over 15,000 titles available globally on Netflix, according to a 2023 report by Statista, many high-quality shows get lost in the shuffle. “Algorithmic recommendations often prioritize mainstream content, leaving lesser-known series in the shadows,” says media analyst Rebecca Lin. “Viewers who venture beyond the ‘Top 10’ row frequently discover exceptional narratives that resonate deeply.”
These three underrated shows have garnered critical acclaim but remain overlooked by broader audiences:
- “Maniac” (2018) – A surreal dark comedy with Emma Stone and Jonah Hill
- “The OA” (2016-2019) – A mind-bending sci-fi mystery
- “Unbelievable” (2019) – A harrowing yet empowering crime drama
1. “Maniac”: A Surreal Journey Through Mental Health and Connection
Starring Emma Stone and Jonah Hill, “Maniac” blends dark humor with poignant storytelling. The limited series follows two strangers who participate in a mysterious pharmaceutical trial, leading to surreal adventures within their own minds. Despite its A-list cast, the show flew under the radar upon release.
“Maniac’s brilliance lies in its ability to balance absurdity with emotional depth,” notes TV critic David Chen. “It’s a rare gem that tackles mental health with both sensitivity and creativity.”
Key highlights:
- Visually stunning cinematography inspired by 1980s sci-fi
- A hauntingly beautiful score by Dan Romer
- Exploration of trauma, loneliness, and human connection
2. “The OA”: A Mind-Bending Mystery That Defies Genre
Created by Brit Marling and Zal Batmanglij, “The OA” is a genre-defying series that combines sci-fi, fantasy, and metaphysical themes. The story revolves around Prairie Johnson, a blind woman who reappears after seven years with her sight restored—and a mysterious new ability.
Despite its cancellation after two seasons, the show developed a passionate fanbase. “The OA challenges viewers to think beyond conventional storytelling,” says sci-fi author Lena Nguyen. “Its ambitious narrative structure and philosophical undertones make it unforgettable.”
Why it stands out:
- Unique blend of mystery, spirituality, and science fiction
- Stellar performances, particularly by Brit Marling
- A cliffhanger finale that sparks endless theories
3. “Unbelievable”: A Powerful Crime Drama Based on True Events
This gripping miniseries, based on a Pulitzer Prize-winning article, follows a young woman accused of lying about her rape and the female detectives who uncover a disturbing pattern of crimes. With a 98% Rotten Tomatoes score, “Unbelievable” is one of Netflix’s highest-rated shows—yet it remains underseen.
“The series handles its sensitive subject matter with remarkable care,” says criminal justice advocate Maria Garcia. “It sheds light on systemic failures while celebrating resilience and justice.”
Notable aspects:
- Outstanding performances by Kaitlyn Dever, Toni Collette, and Merritt Wever
- A nuanced portrayal of trauma and perseverance
- Timely commentary on gender bias in law enforcement
How to Find More Underrated Netflix Shows
Netflix’s algorithm tends to favor new releases and heavily marketed content. To discover hidden gems:
- Browse genre-specific categories rather than the homepage
- Check critic reviews on platforms like Rotten Tomatoes or Metacritic
- Join online communities (e.g., Reddit’s r/NetflixBestOf) for recommendations
The Future of Underrated Content on Streaming Platforms
As streaming services prioritize big-budget productions, smaller shows risk getting buried. However, industry experts predict a shift. “Viewers are increasingly seeking unique stories over flashy franchises,” notes entertainment journalist Ryan Parker. “Platforms may soon invest more in promoting diverse, under-the-radar content.”
For now, these three underrated Netflix shows offer a refreshing alternative to mainstream hits. Whether you’re in the mood for psychological depth, sci-fi intrigue, or real-world drama, they deliver unforgettable experiences.
Ready to dive in? This weekend, skip the usual suspects and give these hidden gems a chance—you might just find your new favorite show.
See more CNET Live