The CW network has long been a staple in the world of television, producing a diverse array of shows ranging from teen dramas to supernatural thrillers. While the network has had its share of smash hits—such as *Supernatural*, *Arrow*, and *The Vampire Diaries*—there are numerous shows that have slipped under the radar, deserving more attention and recognition. These “hidden gems” often faced challenges such as competing in crowded time slots, changing audiences, or a lack of effective promotion. Despite these obstacles, many of these shows demonstrated exceptional storytelling, engaging characters, and unique premises. This article delves into some of the CW’s underrated series that deserved a brighter spotlight and the reasons they remain beloved by a dedicated fanbase.
Understanding The CW’s Programming Landscape
The CW has built its identity around a blend of high-concept dramas, young adult content, and supernatural series. With hits like *The Flash* and *Riverdale*, the network has often leaned into shows that attract younger audiences, particularly those seeking escapism, romance, and intrigue. However, not all of its series fit into this mold, and some stood out for their complexity, emotional depth, or unique themes.
Many of these hidden gems were overshadowed by larger, more mainstream hits, and their initial runs were often short-lived. This has been a frustrating trend for many fans who found themselves invested in these underappreciated series, only to see them canceled before they could reach their full potential. However, the quality of storytelling and the impact these shows had on their audiences continue to leave a lasting legacy.
The Underrated Shows That Deserved More
Below are a few standout series that, despite their potential, struggled to gain mainstream recognition during their original runs but are now regarded as hidden gems in the CW lineup.
1. *Cult* (2013)
Premiering in 2013, *Cult* was a psychological thriller centered around a TV show within a TV show. The series followed a young production assistant, Jeff Sefton, who gets drawn into the world of a cult-like fan base of a fictional TV series, *Cult*. The show cleverly blended the themes of media influence, fandom obsession, and the blurred lines between reality and fiction. Despite its intriguing premise and an engaging performance by Matt Davis, *Cult* was canceled after just one season due to low ratings.
The show gained a loyal fan following and was praised for its self-aware commentary on fandom culture, something that was ahead of its time in 2013. However, its complexity and niche appeal made it difficult for broader audiences to latch onto, leading to its premature cancellation.
2. *The Secret Circle* (2011-2012)
Adapted from the book series by L.J. Smith, *The Secret Circle* combined elements of teen drama with witchcraft, creating a supernatural narrative that could have easily become another *The Vampire Diaries*-like hit for the network. The series, which followed a group of high school students who discover their magical powers, had all the right ingredients for success: a compelling mythology, strong chemistry between the leads, and a fanbase eager for more supernatural intrigue.
Unfortunately, the series was cut short after just one season due to declining viewership. Still, *The Secret Circle* holds a special place in the hearts of its fans. The show’s exploration of power dynamics, relationships, and personal discovery offered a unique take on the genre that deserved a longer run.
3. *Jane the Virgin* (2014-2019)
While *Jane the Virgin* did receive some recognition during its run, including Golden Globe wins, it remains one of the CW’s more underrated successes. This delightful telenovela-inspired dramedy, starring Gina Rodriguez, was lauded for its witty storytelling, diverse representation, and its ability to balance humor with emotional depth. The series told the story of Jane Villanueva, a devout Catholic woman who is accidentally inseminated via artificial insemination, throwing her life into turmoil.
The show cleverly blended romance, comedy, and drama with a sharp sense of satire and cultural commentary. Despite its critical acclaim, *Jane the Virgin* was sometimes overlooked by mainstream audiences, particularly those outside its target demographic. The show’s intricate plotlines and unique format may have made it harder to market, but it remains one of the network’s most beloved offerings.
4. *No Tomorrow* (2016-2017)
*No Tomorrow* was a quirky romantic comedy that centered around Evie, a woman who falls for Xavier, a man who believes that the world is going to end in eight months. The show combined elements of romance, adventure, and life-affirming lessons about living in the present. Despite its charming characters and positive messages, *No Tomorrow* struggled with low ratings and was canceled after just one season.
The series explored the idea of seizing the moment and following one’s passions, touching on deep philosophical themes in a lighthearted manner. Its feel-good narrative, along with its unique premise, earned it a dedicated fanbase, but it was not enough to secure the show’s future beyond its freshman year.
5. *Star-Crossed* (2014)
Set in a world where humans and aliens coexist, *Star-Crossed* followed the relationship between a human girl and an alien boy, tackling themes of prejudice, acceptance, and forbidden love. Despite its fantastical premise and interesting social commentary, the show struggled to maintain a consistent audience and was ultimately canceled after just one season.
What made *Star-Crossed* unique was its exploration of social issues through the lens of a sci-fi romance, making it more than just another teen drama. With its talented cast and strong emotional core, *Star-Crossed* left many viewers wishing it had received more of a chance to develop its characters and storyline.
Why These Shows Were Underrated
The reasons these shows failed to garner the attention they deserved are multifaceted. First and foremost, many of these series were competing for viewership in a crowded television landscape, where it was difficult to stand out among other popular shows. Additionally, some of these series aired during time slots that were already occupied by CW juggernauts, making it hard for newer or niche shows to gain traction.
Another issue was the marketing strategy (or lack thereof). Some of these series were not heavily promoted, and many viewers may not have even been aware of them. For example, *No Tomorrow* and *Cult* were both innovative shows, but they didn’t have the same level of buzz around them as other CW programs.
The Impact of Fandoms and Cult Followings
Despite their early cancellations, many of these shows gained dedicated fanbases over time. This highlights the power of niche audiences in shaping the legacy of a TV series. Fandoms play a crucial role in keeping shows alive through online campaigns, fan art, and social media movements that can sometimes even result in shows being revived or having their storylines continued in other formats.
For example, *The Secret Circle* and *Star-Crossed* both gained a cult following, with fans consistently pushing for a second season or a revival. These devoted communities often keep the spirit of a show alive long after it has left the airwaves.
Conclusion: A Call for Reappraisal
While *The CW* continues to churn out popular programming, there’s no denying that some of its most underrated shows deserve a second look. From *Cult* to *Jane the Virgin*, these shows offered something fresh, different, and compelling—qualities that are sometimes lost in the rush to chase mainstream success. For fans who were lucky enough to discover these hidden gems, they will always have a special place in television history.
In an era where streaming platforms and digital media provide more opportunities for niche content to find its audience, perhaps it’s time for *The CW* to reappraise some of these shows. With fan-driven campaigns and the evolving entertainment landscape, there’s always a chance for these underrated gems to be rediscovered—and perhaps even revived—for a new generation of viewers.
For more information on *The CW*’s current and past shows, you can visit their official website here.
See more CNET Live