In an ambitious move that is stirring the competitive landscape of true crime media, Jason Sarlanis, the president of Investigation Discovery (ID), has unveiled a bold new direction for the network, one that challenges streaming giants like Netflix. By releasing a high-profile special on Aaron Hernandez, ID is not only raising the stakes in true crime content but also signaling a larger shift in how traditional networks are positioning themselves against on-demand streaming services. The decision to spotlight Hernandez’s controversial life and tragic downfall is more than just a program choice—it’s part of a broader strategy to redefine the genre and disrupt the streaming content market.
Investigation Discovery’s Bold Challenge to Streaming Giants
Jason Sarlanis’s recent announcement regarding the upcoming Aaron Hernandez special illustrates how Investigation Discovery is shifting from its traditional role as a niche network to a more aggressive player in the competitive streaming arena. The network, which has built its reputation on captivating true crime documentaries and series, has recognized the growing influence of platforms like Netflix and Hulu and is moving to reclaim its place at the forefront of true crime content creation.
Netflix, for example, has been synonymous with true crime for years, with hits like *Making a Murderer* and *The Trials of Gabriel Fernandez* dominating global discussions. But ID, a long-established network with a dedicated fan base, is seeking to capitalize on its specialized expertise in the genre by offering deeper, more investigative takes on infamous true crime stories. This new Aaron Hernandez special is expected to offer a comprehensive look into his life, trial, and the controversy surrounding his criminal activities, raising questions about the ethics of media portrayals in such high-profile cases.
The Aaron Hernandez Case: A National Obsession
The Aaron Hernandez story is one of the most compelling and tragic narratives to emerge from recent years. The former NFL star, who was convicted of murder and later took his own life in prison, has been the subject of widespread media coverage and several high-profile documentaries. His life and crimes have fascinated the public, with discussions surrounding his mental health, his troubled past, and his sudden fall from grace.
ID’s decision to focus on Hernandez aligns with its commitment to telling deeply human stories that transcend simple crime reporting. While Netflix has already aired *Killer Inside: The Mind of Aaron Hernandez*, this new special from Investigation Discovery promises to take a different approach. According to Sarlanis, the special will provide an in-depth examination of the psychological and social factors that may have contributed to Hernandez’s downfall, incorporating new insights and a range of expert opinions.
Traditional Networks Stepping Up in the Age of Streaming
The battle between traditional television networks and streaming services is intensifying. As consumers increasingly turn to streaming platforms for their entertainment needs, cable networks and broadcast television are under increasing pressure to innovate and stay relevant. Netflix and other platforms, which have enjoyed a significant head start, continue to dominate the entertainment landscape, but traditional media companies are beginning to fight back by adapting their strategies.
Investigation Discovery’s move into Netflix’s turf reflects a broader trend in the television industry. Networks like HBO, A&E, and even National Geographic have increasingly turned to true crime content as a way to capture the attention of modern audiences. The success of shows like *The Jinx* and *The Keepers* has proven that there is still a significant appetite for high-quality, well-researched true crime series. By embracing the genre more aggressively, ID is attempting to redefine its brand while challenging streaming giants to match its expertise in the true crime space.
The Role of True Crime in Modern Media Consumption
True crime has become one of the most popular and enduring genres in modern media. It resonates with audiences on multiple levels, combining mystery, drama, and often sensationalized details about real-life events. In recent years, documentaries and series centered around notorious criminals and unsolved mysteries have gained a loyal following. From *Making a Murderer* to *The People v. O.J. Simpson*, these stories have tapped into a collective fascination with crime and justice.
However, as the genre continues to grow, so do the ethical concerns about sensationalism and exploitation. Many critics have pointed out that true crime content often oversimplifies or misrepresents the complexities of criminal cases, focusing more on shock value than on delivering nuanced narratives. The public’s hunger for these stories can sometimes cloud the issues of justice, and it’s important that creators approach these subjects with sensitivity and responsibility.
As ID moves forward with its new Aaron Hernandez special, it will need to walk this fine line. The network has made it clear that it intends to focus not just on the sensational aspects of Hernandez’s story but also on the deeper questions of identity, mental illness, and the impact of fame on individuals. This approach could set the special apart from other true crime content by prioritizing a more thoughtful and balanced exploration of the case.
Investigation Discovery’s Unique Approach to True Crime
What sets Investigation Discovery apart from Netflix and other streaming platforms is its long-standing reputation for producing content with a strong investigative angle. While Netflix and HBO focus on broad narratives that appeal to a wide range of viewers, ID has carved out a niche by zeroing in on cases that might not have received as much attention in the mainstream media.
One of the reasons for ID’s success is its commitment to detail. The network frequently works with law enforcement, legal experts, and journalists to ensure that its documentaries are as accurate as possible. This focus on thorough research has allowed ID to build a loyal audience that trusts the network to deliver reliable, in-depth analyses of true crime stories. As competition from streaming services intensifies, ID’s ability to provide unique insights and offer a deep dive into high-profile cases gives it an edge.
Broader Implications for the True Crime Industry
As traditional media outlets like ID challenge the dominance of streaming platforms, the true crime industry is likely to see significant changes in the years ahead. Audiences are becoming more discerning, with an increasing demand for content that goes beyond surface-level drama and offers fresh perspectives. This means that both traditional networks and streaming platforms will need to adapt by producing more original and thought-provoking content.
Moreover, as the public’s interest in true crime shows no sign of waning, issues of ethics, accuracy, and responsibility in the portrayal of criminal cases will continue to be at the forefront. It’s likely that future true crime documentaries and specials will evolve to include more input from experts, victims’ families, and communities affected by crime. As networks like ID, Netflix, and others vie for audience attention, they will need to balance the allure of sensational stories with a deeper commitment to responsible storytelling.
Conclusion: A New Era for True Crime
Jason Sarlanis’s bold move to challenge Netflix and other streaming platforms with Investigation Discovery’s new Aaron Hernandez special reflects a larger shift in the entertainment industry. As traditional networks adapt to the digital age, true crime content is becoming more than just a genre—it is a battleground for viewership and influence. With its deep commitment to investigation and its nuanced approach to sensitive topics, ID has a unique opportunity to redefine how audiences consume true crime content.
As the landscape continues to evolve, one thing is clear: audiences are hungry for more compelling, in-depth stories about crime and justice. The challenge for networks and streaming services alike will be to deliver content that not only satisfies this hunger but also elevates the conversation around criminal justice, mental health, and the impact of media on public perception.
- Read more about true crime streaming trends on CNBC
- Explore Investigation Discovery’s full slate of documentaries and specials
See more CNET Live